Reading time: minutes
March
2024

Development: A North-South Debate

In the name of aid, progress, growth, empowerment or sustainability, development has always had the sense of being something "good" or "positive". But poverty and inequality are outcomes of the systematic and unequal integration of "poorer" countries into the global economic structures. Learn more about this with a timeline of western development politics, its criticism and movements fighting for alternative concepts to improve and change the world.

Development in Politics

Whether it's called development aid, development cooperation or development policy - development is a controversial field in politics and repeatedly sparks criticism and debate. Generally speaking, development can be understood as activities that aim to improve a country's economic, social, societal or technical situation.

 

Who Really Benefits From the Development

Graphic with many arrows
Even if this concept of development sounds neutral at first, it is not. It implies the idea of a "highly developed", "modern" and "civilized" (external link, opens in a new window)west, that helps the global south to "progress" by providing technology, money and culture. In a way, the world remains divided: between the West and the rest, the developed and the underdeveloped, those in possession of solutions and those in need of help.

The History of "Development"

In this idea of development, power hierarchies and imbalances between countries, people, economies and institutions are deeply rooted. A look at history shows that this is no coincidence: development in this sense is a legacy of colonialism, which is based on the exploitation of people and nature and is intended to maintain this. As such, development is also closely linked to the current economic system of capitalism with its ultimate goal of economic growth.

This timeline traces the emergence of development from its colonial beginnings to its current form.

The History of Development

Critical Perspectives of Capitalist Development

As it turns out, global inequality is not a technical problem or a flaw in the system, but one that requires rethinking society as a whole. Development policy is an important means for the West to stabilize and constantly re-establish this global injustice and dominance in the world. So if we want to criticize the understanding of development described above, we must also question all the principles associated with it: A worldview that favors and centers Europe (Eurocentrism), capitalism and economic growth in general.

 

Das folgende Video bietet eine grundlegende Kritik an der Idee von Entwicklung als Wirtschaftswachstum. Es soll dabei helfen, dieses System zu analysieren und eine kritische Perspektive auf das Thema einzunehmen.

Critical perspectives of capitalist Development

Decolonizing and Re-imagining Development

The ideas of capitalism and development are spread throughout Western societies in a very dominant way; to the extent that it seems almost impossible to change anything or imagine alternatives. While the Global North is fundamentally founded on capitalism, for ‘developing’ countries capitalism is the goal they are supposed to strive for. In this context, it is high time to challenge these dominant concepts:

  • by moving away from the European experience of industrial growth and capitalist expansion
  • by shifting the focus away from current understandings of economy
  • by decolonizing policies in relation to development.

In the following method, you can learn about some ideas to transform and decolonize development.

Decolonizing and Re-imagining Development

Alternative concepts, grassroots movements and resistance against capitalist development

Alternatives to development does not mean looking for alternatives to development or alternative ways to become like the West. Rather, it involves a fundamental shift from the universal model of Western development to existing alternatives of self organizing among those most affected from the development project. Alternatives come from the grassroots movements and local communities from around the globe, especially in the Global South.

The following world map provides an interactive learning experience to the user with a compilation of concepts, worldviews, practices, social movements and resistances that question the modernist ideology of development and go beyond those practices based on their cultural contexts.

Alternative Concepts, Grassroots Movements and Resistance Against Capitalist Development

Sources: Development

Using and Sharing!

This article is part of the series Exiting the Crisis! - Understanding Crises and Paths to Global Justice, which was produced in cooperation with Konzeptwerk Neue Ökonomie (external link, opens in a new window). Online Editing by Alina Kopp. This article is published under the terms of the Creative Commons License CC BY 4.0 (external link, opens in a new window)! Share, use or adapt it for your educational work. Don't forget to republish it under the same conditions and mention L!NX and the authors.

All Articles

Climate Catastrophe, Inequality, Exploitation - I'm Having a Crisis

Why is the world the way it is? In the following you'll find an introduction to selected socio-ecological crises. It highlights the connections between the climate crisis, the ecological crisis, gender relations, abundance, privileges and unjust global power relations. You will learn about the connections between capitalism and historically evolved global structures of exploitation.

View

Free Trade: Alternatives, Actors and Resistance

Modern world trade has its roots in colonialism and is determined by the economic interests of powerful governments and transnational corporations. Free trade is a trade policy that is supposed to bring more growth and prosperity for everyone involved. But who really benefits from it and at what cost? We examine how and why free trade came about, how trade could be made fairer and highlight movements that oppose the current world trade order.

View

Future Mobility: Can Electric Cars Solve the Climate Crisis?

As the second-largest emitter of greenhouse gases, transportation is a driving factor for the climate crisis. Find out what politicians are doing about it, why these plans are being criticised by Chile's population and why workers' struggles and climate struggles go together. Afterwards, chat with Maxi from the future and find out how things could be done differently.

View

Development: A North-South Debate

In the name of aid, progress, growth, empowerment or sustainability, development has always had the sense of being something "good" or "positive". But poverty and inequality are outcomes of the systematic and unequal integration of "poorer" countries into the global economic structures. Learn more about this with a timeline of western development politics, its criticism and movements fighting for alternative concepts to improve and change the world.

View

Food Sovereignity: Good Food for All

Anyone who deals with the topic of agriculture and climate will realize that agriculture is both the cause and the victim of the climate crisis. However, agriculture cannot simply be abolished or replaced. But can it be made more climate-resistant and climate-friendly?

View

Ready for a Better Future?

We live in a time in which one crisis follows the next: Pandemic, war, poverty, flight, climate crisis or even the collapse of the financial system. How can we still not lose sight of our dreams and utopias, take action and what can give us orientation?

View

Can Green Capitalism Stop the Climate Crisis?

The destructive effects of capitalism on the environment are supposed to be transformed through the use of new technologies or ecological business models. But this cannot ensure genuine socio-ecological change and a good life for all. We need a system change based on the principles of solidarity and care.

View
Bild von einem Barista, Bagger, Holz, Lastwagen und Fertigungsanlagen.

No Time for Care Work?

Who runs the household when all the adult members of a family work eight hours a day? Coming home, picking up the children on the way and quickly doing some errands before cooking and tidying up - where is the time left for leisure, relationships or political work? You can find out here who still has this time, who doesn't and how things can be done differently.

View

This might also interest you